Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 1 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Code Change Cycle:
2013 Triennial Original Modification 7/1/2012 ‑ 8/2/2012    Standing Motion: 
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Sub Code:
Energy Conservation
7‑Appendix A
Section
Pending Review
100
Ann Stanton
 6006 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Appendix A from 2010 FBC Energy Conservation code.
7

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Geyselears
X

W

I

9‑Appendix C
Section
Pending Review
Form C402
Ann Stanton
 6009 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Need to update energy code form for commercial prescriptive code compliance.
9

NAR – needs to be made consistent with actions made today and provide additional information.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Geyselears

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
Form R400D
Ann Stanton
 6010 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Need to update energy code form for residential prescriptive code compliance.
9

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Geyselears
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
Form R402
Ann Stanton
 6008 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Need to update energy code form for residential prescriptive code compliance.
9

NAR – to be made consistent with other actions today.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Fairey

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 2 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
1‑ [CE] ‑ Scope and Administration
Section
Pending Review
C101.4.10
Ann Stanton
 5067 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific Limited or special use buildings category to the code from the 2010 FBC.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
7Y-2N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C101.4.1
Ann Stanton
 5059 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific table, Applicability, Existing Buildings, from 2010 code.
1

NAR – recommended resolving statutorily.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Sanders

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C101.4.3
Amanda Hickman
 5959 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds exception to list for Additions, alterations, renovations or repairs to an existing building.
1
As amended with Alternate 1.
Motion to reconsider Sanders 2nd Greiner
Motion to approve A1 as an amendment- Fairey 2nd – Sanders
Motion to approve as amended – Fairey  2nd –Cochell – Vote 8Y-1N
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Fairey

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C101.4.7
Ann Stanton
 5065 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Building systems language for replacement equipment to code from 2010 FBC.
1
Motion to amend using original mode plus A3 Sanders 2nd Geyselaers. Vote 9Y-0N
Motion to approve as amended Fairey -2nd Bailey  Vote 9Y-0N
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

Sanders

X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 3 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C101.4.8
Ann Stanton
 5066 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific code exemptions to the 2013 code.
1
Moti0n to approve original mod with A2 Cochell 2nd Fairey Vote 9Y-0N
Motion to approve as amended, Fairey – 2nd Geyselaers. Vote 9Y-0N
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

Cochell

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C101.4.9
Ann Stanton
 5691 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific criteria for shell buildings.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C101.5.1
Ann Stanton
 5071 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific compliance maters requirements to the 2013 code.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C103.1.1
Ann Stanton
 5069 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific commercial &amp; residential high-rise building certification criteria to the 2013 FBC.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
7Y-2N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C103.2.1
Cheryl Harris
 5876 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to Code Compliance forms for Energy Calculations
1

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 4 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C103.2.3
Cheryl Harris
 5825 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to energy calculations
1

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C107‑109
Ann Stanton
 5695 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Reserve FL‑specific administrative provisions.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Bailey
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C110
Ann Stanton
 5073 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add reporting requirements from the 2010 energy code.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

1‑ [RE] ‑ Scope and Administration
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.1
Ann Stanton
 5030 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Clarify Florida‑specific applicability of energy code criteria for existing buildings.
1

NAR – should be resolved statutorily.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
3Y-5N
Sanders

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 5 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.3
Amanda Hickman
 5957 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds exception to list for Additions, alterations, renovations or repairs to an existing building.
1

Motion to approve A1 standing on rationale Fairey 2nd Geyselaers Vote – 9Y-0Y

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

Fairey

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R101.4.7.1.1
Cheryl Harris
 5807 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To modify Florida specific code related to duct sealing
1

NAR – in preference of another mod.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Fairey

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.7.1.2
Cheryl Harris
 5809 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To modify the Florida Specific Code related to replacement equipment sizing
1

NAR – covered by another mod.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
5Y-4N
Sanders

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.7.1.2
Cheryl Harris
 5811 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To modify the Florida Specific Code related to replacement equipment sizing
1

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.7.1.3
Cheryl Harris
 5820 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain the Florida Specific Code related to replacement equipment efficiencies.
1

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 6 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.7
Ann Stanton
 5031 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Include provisions for new Building systems installed in existing buildings per Ch. 553.903, FS.
1

Motion to approve original mod with A3 Sanders 2nd Fairey – Vote 9Y-0N

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R101.4.7
Cheryl Harris
 5806 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific code related to Building Systems
1

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R101.4.8
Ann Stanton
 5032 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Provides Florida‑specific code exemptions per S. 553.905, FS, etc.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Geyselaers
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R101.5.1
Ann Stanton
 5693 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific code compliance forms for residential buildings.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Fairey
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R103.1.1
Ann Stanton
 5033 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Provides for Florida‑specific code compliance certification.
1

Sanders Approve as per A-1 standing on opponents rationale.  
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders

X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 7 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R103.2.1
Cheryl Harris
 5824 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to Code Compliance forms for Energy Calculations
1

Motion died due to lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R103.2.3
Cheryl Harris
 5829 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to energy calculations
1

Motion dies due to lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R107‑109
Ann Stanton
 5696 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Reserve FL‑specific administrative provisions.
1

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
6Y-1N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R110
Ann Stanton
 5058 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add energy code reporting forms from 2010 code.
1
NAR – covered in commercial section of the code.  Currently in Chapter 1 of the FBC, B and should pertain to both, but does not. 4Y-4N
Motion to reconsider Cochell-2nd Sanders.  Vote 9Y-0N
2nd Fairy – 
Vote 9Y-0N AS

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
Sanders
X

W

I

2‑ [CE] ‑ Definitions
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 8 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C202 General Definitions
Ken Cureton
 5072 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add and / or modify Chapter 2 definitions of terms included in the proposed modifications listed in Related Modifications item above.
2
Motion to reconsider Fairy 2nd Caldwell Vote 8Y-1N
2nd Fairey for negative roll call.  Vote 0Y-9N
NAR – determine which definitions are necessary and bring forth during comment period.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders

W

I
X
2‑ [RE] ‑ Definitions
Section
Pending Review
R202
Ann Stanton
 5660 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Bring forward applicable Florida‑specific definitions from the 2010 FBC‑Energy Conservation.
2

NAR – additional clarifying definition needed based on previous actions.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Sanders

W

I
X
3‑ [CE] ‑ General Requirements
Section
Pending Review
C303.2.3
Cheryl Harris
 5833 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to recessed equipment and insulation requirements
3

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C304
Ann Stanton
 5077 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific materials testing and thermal properties criteria from the 2010 FBC.
3

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Palacios
X

W

I

3‑ [RE] ‑ General Requirements
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 9 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R301
Michael Nau
 4995 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
This proposal increases Climate Zone 1 by the inclusion of Palm Beach, Hendry, Collier and Lee Counties
3

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R303.2.3
Cheryl Harris
 5832 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to recessed equipment and insulation requirements
3

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R303
Ann Stanton
 5034 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Provides Florida‑specific criteria for insulation installation and calculation.
3

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

4‑ [CE] ‑ Commercial Energy Efficiency
Section
Pending Review
C402.2
Mark Nowak
 5447 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Provides climate‑appropriate R‑values for metal framing.
4

NAR – does not agree with ASHRAE standards.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
2Y-7N
Cochell

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 10 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C402.2
Larry Williams
 5452 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds a footnote to Table C402.2 to recognize alternative assemblies for efficient framing methods
4

NAR – TAC requesting additional data to support the mod.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Geyselaers

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C402.4.9 Building cavities
Kenneth Cureton
 4938 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add section C402.4.9 Building cavities
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Bailey
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C403.2.1
Ken Cureton
 4964 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
MODIFY section C403.2.1 as follows:
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Geyselaers
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C403.2.1
Cheryl Harris
 5848 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida specific code related to calculation of heating and cooling loads
4

Motion dies for lack of 2nd. 
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.2
Cheryl Harris
 5851 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific code relate to equipment sizing
4

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 11 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.3 (1)
Ann Stanton
 5803 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Update Table C403.2.3 (1) to federal efficiencies effective 1/1/15.
4

NAR - to allow proponent to provide additional research information and staff analysis of federal requirements.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Fairey

W

I
x
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.3 (2)
Ann Stanton
 5804 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Update Table C403.2.3 (2) to federal efficiencies effective 1/1/15.
4

NAR – to allow staff analysis of federal requirements.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Bailey

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.3 (4)
Ann Stanton
 5805 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Update Table C403.2.3 (4) to federal efficiencies effective 1/1/15.
4

NAR – TAC requests proponent incorporates G2 language into modification.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Geyselaers

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.3 (7)
Jerry Paul
 5125 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
In Table C403.2.3(7), combine the water cooled, electrically operated, positive displacement and centrifugal chiller categories into a single category, &quot;Water cooled electrically operated chillers&quot; with the higher energy efficiency requirements now achievable by all.
4

Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W
X
I

Section
Pending Review
C403.2.4.3.4
Ken Cureton
 4968 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Section C403.2.4.3.4 Humidistatic Control
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 12 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.4
Robert Volin
 5877 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add sizing calculations as per current code
4

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
C403.2.7
Ken Cureton
 4969 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
MODIFY section C403.2.7 Duct and plenum insulation and sealing as follows
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C403.4.8
Ken Cureton
 4970 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
ADD section C403.4.8 ‑ Condensing coils installed in cool air stream of another air‑conditioning unit as follows
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C404.7
Ann Stanton
 5060 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specifc language that requires pool heaters to meet minimum efficiencies as in the 2010 FBC.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C404.8
Ken Cureton
 4971 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
ADD section C404.8 Water flow rate controls as follows
4

Recommendation to proponent to add statutory references where appropriate.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 13 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C405.7
Ken Cureton
 4989 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
MODIFY section C405.7 Electrical power as follows
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.2.1
Ann Stanton
 5215 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
The performance method of the IECC has no code minimum for insulation in the roof. The Florida‑specific from the 2010 FBC‑Energy Conservation is proposed.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Fairey
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.3
Muthusamy Swami
 5837 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Modifies C407.3 Performance‑based compliance to make energy cost used in the calculation uniform.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.4
Ann Stanton
 5740 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Make documentation of software Florida‑specific.
4
Motion to approve as amended to delete reference to the manual by Sanders. 2nd Sanders – Vote 8Y-0N
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Geyselaers

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.5.1 (1)
Muthusamy Swami
 5845 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
TABLE C407.5.1 (1)—continued
SPECIFICATIONS FOR THE STANDARD REFERENCE AND PROPOSED DESIGNS
to make calculation process uniform
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 14 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
C407.5.2.4
Muthusamy Swami
 5849 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds section C407.5.2.4 to deal with vegetative roofs and ERV creditd
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.5.3.2
Muthusamy Swami
 5860 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds new Section C407.5.3 that modifies section 11.3.2 from the referenced standard ASHRAE 90.1
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.5.3
Muthusamy Swami
 5853 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds table Table C407.5.3.1 HVAC Systems to modify referenced ASHRAE standard 90.1
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C407.6.1
Ann Stanton
 5778 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Make &quot;specific approvals&quot; Florida specific.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
C408.2.2
Ken Cureton
 4990 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
MODIFY section C408.2.2 Air distribution system testing, adjusting and balancing as follows
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 15 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
4‑ [RE] ‑ Residential Energy Efficiency
Section
Pending Review
R401.3
Ann Stanton
 5050 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Replace IECC requirement for certificate with Florida requirement for EPL Disiplay Card as required by Florida law.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R402.1.1 &amp; 402.1.3
Michael Nau
 4987 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
This proposal establishes a U‑factor for Climate Zone 1 and makes allowances for impact product in Florida in the 2013 Code.
4

Motion to accept Alt 1. Cochell 2nd Sanders Vote 9Y-0N

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

Cochell

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R402.1.1
Dwight Wilkes
 5698 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To reinstate the current Florida footnote to Table R402.1.1 in the Base code [2012 IECC] for impact rated fenestration products with modification to U‑factor.
4

Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W
X
I

Section
Pending Review
R402.2.12
Ann Stanton
 5697 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific criteria for installing air handlers in attics.
4

Motion to include the provision of R1 and the original mod, Cochell 2nd Sanders, Vote 8Y-1N

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

Cochell

X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 16 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R402.3.6
Michael Nau
 5000 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
This proposal establishes the current 2010 code values for replacement fenestration in the 2013 Code
4

NAR – proponent to provide clarification utilizing comments of the TAC.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Cochell

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R402.3.6
Joseph Belcher
 6022 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Modification to replacement window provisions.
4

NAR – modification is in the realm of issues to be resolved by statute.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Fairey

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R402.4.1.2
Arlene Stewart
 5624 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Proposal cross references Florida statute on certified professionals as applicable to the IECC provision
4

NAR – not appropriate based on law.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Fairey

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R402.4.1.2
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 6013 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Raise building air leakage rate limit, provide air leakage testing standard and clarify who is qualified to test air leakage.
4
Motion to amend by striking the words ‘Class I Florida Rater’ from the modification based on proponents rationale. Fairey 2nd Geyselaers 
Amendment withdrawn.
2nd with a request for negative roll call to remove ‘Class I Florida Rater’ and TAC suggests proponent to review comments.  Vote: 0Y-9N

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

Fairey

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R402.5 and R405.5.3
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5605 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
THIS MODIFICATION APPLIES STRICTLY TO THE PERFORMANCE METHOD. This modification removes irrelevant climate‑zone U‑factor requirements from the performance method and moves performance compliance maximum fenestration SHGC requirement to Section R405.5.3 and provides overhang depth alternative.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 17 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R402.6
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5662 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Limitations to compliance by Section R402.
4

NAR - To strike the area in the portions that are not concurrent with Florida law.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Sanders

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.1
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5666 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Clarify programmable thermostat requirements.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R403.2.1
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 6015 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Prescriptive compliance duct location and insulation.
4

NAR – due to a combination of R value and conditioned space seems redundant.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Cochell

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.2.2
Arlene Stewart
 5628 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Proposal cross references Florida statute on certified professionals as applicable to the IECC provision
4

NAR – based on previous TAC action and proponents recommendation.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Geyselaers

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.2.2
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5677 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Provide duct leakage testing standard, clarify duct leakage testing qualification requirements and remove leakage testing exception for ducts and air handlers within the building thermal envelope.
4

NAR – based on TAC action on previous mod and mod specifies particular group of raters which not within Florida law.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-8N
Fairey

W

I
X
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 18 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R403.2.2
Ann Stanton
 5763 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Propose Florida‑specific duct sealing and attachment standards.
4

NAR – to allow language clean up in accordance with comments on mod 5677.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-8N
Maxwell

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.2.4
Cheryl Harris
 5051 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to air handling units in attics
4
2nd Withdrawn
Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.2.4
Robert Volin
 5873 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add sizing calculations as per current code
4
Dies for lack of No Second
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

None

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.4.3
Ann Stanton
 5053 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific water heater efficiencies to the 2013 FBC.
4
Motion to Propose to adopt A1 modification standing on proponents rationale.  2nd Fairey – Vote 9Y-0N
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Geyselaers

X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R403.5
Ann Stanton
 5055 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific ventilation air requirements.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 19 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R403.6.1.2 &amp; R403.6.1.3
Cheryl Harris
 5844 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to heating equipment capacity
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Cochell
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R403.6.1
Ann Stanton
 5057 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific equipment sizing criteria from the 2010 code.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R403.6.1
Cheryl Harris
 5843 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
To maintain Florida Specific Code related to equipment sizing
4

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.6.2
Ann Stanton
 5056 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add Florida‑specific efficiencies for HVAC equipment from 2010 code.
4

Motion dies for lack of 2nd.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R403.9
Ann Stanton
 5045 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Move swimming pool criteria from 2010 code forward into the 2013 code.
4
Motion to table 5045 and 5814 until after 6004,  Fairey, 2nd Cochell Vote 9Y-0N
Motion to unable Sanders 2nd Geyselaers Vote 9Y-0N
2nd Fairey Vote 9Y-0N
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 20 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R403.9
Representing FL Swimming Pool Assoc
 5814 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Moves swimming pool and spa criteria from 2010 code, with exception of APSP‑15 reference, forward into the 2013 code.
4
Motion to table 5045 and 5814 until after 6004,  Fairey, 2nd Cochell Vote 9Y-0N
Motion to untable Sanders 2nd Geyselaers Vote 9Y-0N
2nd Bailey Vote 0Y-9N
Duplicative

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R405.2.1
Ann Stanton
 5046 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Include Florida minimum ceiling R‑value of R‑19, space permitting, which has been in Florida law since 1980.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R405.3, Appendix B B‑1
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5699 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Modify section R405.3 to mirror the compliance calculation method used in the 2010 FEC and add Appendix B from 2010 FEC to specify the calculation methods.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9-0N
Fairey
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R405.4
Ann Stanton
 5741 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Make documentation of software Florida‑specific.
4

NAR – correct/strike underline section referring to manual.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Fairey

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R405.5.2 (1)
Mark Nowak
 5445 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Reintroduces mechanical equipment efficiency as a variable in the simulated performance option.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Cochell
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 21 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R405.5.2, R402.1.1, R402.1.3
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5687 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Modify Tables R405.5.2 (1) and R405.5.2 (2) such that the performance efficiencies of the 2012 IECC Standard Reference Design equal or exceed the Florida‑specific performance efficiencies of the 2010 Florida Energy Code and modify Tables R402.1.1 and R402.1.3 to align accordingly.
4
NAR – regarding footnote d, licensing concerns and reference to BERS raters.  Based on comments provided by TAC more work is required in the language.  Adding insulation to the mass walls improves the conditions.  TAC requests hard numbers from the proponent regarding cost benefit analysis in energy usage.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Sanders

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R405.5.3
Ann Stanton
 5047 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Adds Florida‑specific calculation procedures for glazing.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Geyselaers
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R405.6.3
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5943 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Reduce Energy Factors of proposed home instantaneous water heaters for performance compliance calculations.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Fairey
X

W

I

Section
Pending Review
R405.7
Ann Stanton
 5049 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add requirements for residential energy code credit options from 2010 code.
4

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
7Y-2N
Cochell
X

W

I

5‑ [RE] ‑ Referenced Standards
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 22 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 101 
Section
Pending Review
R‑All
Ann Stanton
 6004 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Update standards list to reflect Florida specific references.
5

NAR – waiting for the approval of addenda.
Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
0Y-9N
Cochell

W

I
X
Section
Pending Review
R‑RESNET
Jeff Sonne / FSEC
 5802 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Add RESNET 2006 Mortgage Industry National Home Energy Rating Systems Standards as duct airtightness testing reference.
5

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
8Y-1N
Fairey
X

W

I

5‑ [CE] ‑ Referenced Standards
Section
Pending Review
C‑All
Ann Stanton
 6005 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Update standards list to reflect Florida specific references.
5

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Sanders
X

W

I

Sub Code:
Existing Building
11‑Additions
Section
Pending Review
1106
Ken Cureton
 5871 
Chapter
Mod #
Comment
Summary
Modify SECTION 1106.1
11

Proponent
AS
AM
NAR
TAC Vote:
Second:
9Y-0N
Fairey
X

W

I

AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key

Tracking Chart ‑ All Mods
Page 23 of 23
9/28/2012
Energy
2013 Florida Building Code ‑ TAC review
Modification #:
Code Change Cycle:
Chapter & Topic:
Date Submitted From:
TAC:
Proponent Last Name:
Affects HVHZ:
Sub Code:
Code Version:
Commission Action:
Text of Modification:
Section:
Related Modifications:
TAC Recommendation:
Date Submitted To:
Proponent First Name:
2013
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
EN
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
Search Criteria
AS = Approved as Submitted 	AM = Approved as Modified NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation

W = Withdrawn	I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)

TAC Recommendations Key