Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards Updated 9/1/2010 
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 1 of 28
6/25/2010
Code Change Cycle:
2010 Triennial Original Modification 3/1/2010 ‑ 4/2/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Building
1203.3.2
 3986 
1. Delete Florida Specific amendment to 1203.3.2 and retain IBC language.
2. Change code reference to Chapter 13 of the Florida Building Code, Building
3. Retain exception #5 and renumber to #6.
J Glenn‑BASF
12
Comment
Second  Move to change ref to FBC, EC , Unanimous  Move mod as amended Aye 11 Nay 0 AM
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
New appendix
 4391 
Add a new Appendix “XX” (Designation to be assigned)
Doug Harvey
2711
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11   NAR  Standard not yet final.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
101.2
 3709 
Jurisdictions should be allowed to adopt a more stringent code but not a less stringent one.
Darrell Winters
1
Comment
Second      Aye  0 Nay  11  NAR Contrar  to FL law

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 2 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
101.4.10
 3848 
Allow code official to determine limited/special use building application.
Ann Stanton
1
Comment
Second      Aye  11 Nay  o  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
101.4.10
 4237 
PROPOSED CHANGE IN THERMAL ENVELOPE REQUIREMENTS FOR SPECIAL USE STRUCTURES
WILLIAM KALKER
1
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11   NAR  No FL specific need.  

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
101.4.3
 3731 
Clarify that the exceptions apply where buildings are not exempt from compliance with the code.
Ann Stanton
1
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0   AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
101.5.1
 3847 
Reserve code section that would allow the code official to accept software and other materials for code compliance that are not specified in the code.
Ann Stanton
1
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 3 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
102.1
 3850 
Provide criteria by which code officials may determine code compliance by alternate materials and methods.
Ann Stanton
1
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
202
 3711 
Modifies the definition of &quot;Space Permitting ‑ Insulation.&quot;
Darrell Winters
2
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11   NAR    Unclear, FL law

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
202
 3714 
Add definitions for Absorptance, Multi‑Scene Control and Normative.
Ann Stanton
2
Comment
Second   Move amend def of absorptance “ of the total absorbed radiation” second, unanimous   Move mod as amended.    Aye 11  Nay 0 AM Correct term  
“1- reflectance “
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
202
 4412 
Add lighting‑related definitions per ASHRAE 90.1 Addenda aa.
Ann Stanton
2
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0   AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 4 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
Definitions
 4307 
Add permanent shading to chapter 2 definitions
Amanda Hickman
2
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Def not needed, already covered.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
303.2
 4433 
Add criteria for insulation installation from the appendices of the present Florida energy code that were inadvertently omitted from the Florida‑specific criteria included in the base code.
Ann Stanton
3
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0   AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
304
 4438 
Add criteria for determining thermal properties of building materials and assemblies.
Ann Stanton
3
Comment
Second      Aye  11 Nay  0 AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402
 4080 
Eliminate the “Total UA Alternative” residential energy code compliance method described in section 402.1.1.3.
Jeff Sonne
4
Comment
Second      Aye 8  Nay  3  NAR    Consistency with IECC.  

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 5 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
402.1.1
 3956 
This proposal creates a second option for builders to install roofing materials with a solar reflectance over 0.10, as long as the area‑weighted average fenestration SHGC does not exceed 0.25.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  10  NAR   Would remove reqt for tested sealed duct leakage, would weaken the code.  Move reconsider, second, 9-1.  Smith move readdress A3 would take NR & footnote e off.  Amendment Aye 3 Nay 7  Amendment as drafted 2-8 Mod as submitted. Aye 0 Nay 11 NAR.  

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.1.1
 3957 
This proposal increases energy efficiency, reduces peak demand and sizing of cooling systems, and improves comfort for building occupants by lowering the prescriptive fenestration SHGC value to 0.25.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Second      Aye 4  Nay  7 NAR .25 is unnecessary .3 is low enough .  not cost effective

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.1.1
 4258 
Removing footnote From Table 402.1.1, language that does not apply to FL requirements.
Amy Schmidt
4
Comment
Second      Aye 9  Nay  0   AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.1.1 and 402.1.3
 3955 
This code proposal improves thermal envelope efficiency by increasing the ceiling insulation requirement to R‑38, consistent with U.S. DOE and FSEC recommendations.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR   More restrictive than the performance method.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 6 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
402.1.1 and 402.1.3
 3958 
This proposal saves energy by improving the fenestration and skylight U‑factors, consistent with proposals approved by the IECC Code Development Committee for inclusion in the 2012 IECC.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Second      Aye  0 Nay  11   NAR   Not consistent with IECC.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.1.1.3
 4464 
Clarifies that two options are available to meet the air duct tightness requirements
Jack Glenn
4
Comment
Move to TABLE until consideration of duct testing. Second Unanimous.  Move remove from table, second, unanimous.  Second   Aye 6  Nay 4 NAR It’s not possible to verify that ducts are not leaking to outside without testing them.  
4  NAR Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.2.5
 3943 
Establishes equivalency table for steel framed wall assemblies with stud spacing at 24 inches.
Joe Nebbia
4
Comment
Second      Aye 10  Nay  1  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.3.2.1 (NEW)
 4309 
Adds compliance paths for meeting SHGC values in table 402.1.1.
Amanda Hickman
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Consistent with previous action.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 7 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
402.3.6
 4317 
The SHGC requirements for replacement fenestration in section 402.3.6 can be satisfied by new section 402.3.2.1 on Permanent Shading.
Amanda Hickman
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR Consistent with previous action.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
402.5
 4320 
Delete entire section: 402.5 Maximum fenestration U‑factor and SHGC (Mandatory).
Amanda Hickman
4
Comment
Second      Aye  5 Nay  6  NAR   No FL specific need.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.2.1
 3713 
Requires R‑2 insulation on ducts in conditioned space.
Darrell Winters
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR   Not needed. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.2.1
 4197 
Needs to be in residential code because Manual D applies to Residential and Light commercial duct systems
Robert Volin
4
Comment
Second      Aye 9 Nay  2   AS Motion to reconsider, second, unanimous.  Move to move to new section 403.22.5 second unanimous  Move mod as amended Aye 11 Nay 0 AM

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 8 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
403.2.2.1
 3892 
Add exception per compliance with section 405
Roger Sanders
4
Comment
Second      Aye 7  Nay  4  NAR   Confusing. 

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.2.2.1
 4463 
This modification reinstates the original air duct tightness provisions in the IECC.
Jack Glenn
4
Comment
Second      Aye 6  Nay  5   NAR   Totally confusing.  Test results unclear.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.2.2.1, 403.6.1.1
 4460 
Requires certain equipment sizing and duct sealing requirements upon total replacement of the condensing and evaporator units of residential HVAC systems.  The modification is the consensus language developed by the 2010 Florida Energy Code Workgroup.
Paul Savage
4
Comment
Second   Move A3 as amendment. Second, unanimous.  Move mod as amended, second   Aye  11 Nay  0 AM  Correct per FL law.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.5.1
 4458 
This restores original IECC language for ventilation.
Jack Glenn
4
Comment
Second      Aye 4  Nay  7  NAR   Eliminating FL specific criteria, FL specific need.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Buildieng Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 9 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
403.6, 403.6.1, 403.6.1.1
 4058 
None
Robert Volin
4
Comment
Second      Aye 10 Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.6.2.1.1
 4121 
The DOE is expanding it's  verification of efficiency ratings and increasing it's enforcement in this area.  Meeting their requirements, therefore, should be acceptable for the State of Florida.
roger cummins
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  10  NAR   Makes it more restrictive.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.9
 4078 
This proposal adds Florida specific energy efficiency language for pool heaters, residential filtration pumps and motors, and portable spas per the legislative directive in the 2008 energy bill (HB 7135).  It also makes necessary clarifications under the cover section.
Jennifer Hatfield
4
Comment
Second    Move strike exception for heat pumps from 403.9.3, second, unanimous. Move amendment as amended.second unanimous. :Move mod as double amended, second.    Aye 11  Nay  0 AM

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
403.9.3
 4271 
This proposal removes the cover requirements for pools and spas and clarifies that the R‑12 insulation requirement for covers is only required for portable spas (hot tubs).  The current requirements are unenforceable and pose serious safety hazards.
Jennifer Hatfield
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR Consistent with previous action.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 10 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
405
 4249 
Make a modification to the EnergyGauge USA FlaRes residential energy code compliance software that will facilitate proper window overhang entry and as a result provide more accurate energy code calculations.
Jeff Sonne
4
Comment
Second      Aye  11 Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405
 4322 
Makes two section 405 EnergyGauge USA FlaRes water heater changes:

1) Allow primary heat pump water heater entries and energy factor (EF) entries for primary and add‑on heat pump water heaters

2) Internally modify water heater energy factors based on typical residential water draw profiles.
Jeff Sonne
4
Comment
Second      Aye  11 Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405
 4382 
Relaxes the window area‑weighed average maximum fenestration SHGC requirement for section 405 (performance) code compliance calculations in cases where the window area‑weighted average overhang depth for the entire dwelling unit is 4.0 feet or greater.
Jeff Sonne
4
Comment
Second      Aye  10 Nay  1  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405.2
 3953 
This proposal removes an exception from the mandatory minimum R‑19 ceiling insulation requirement, ensuring a reasonable level of efficiency, regardless of the type of ceiling construction selected by the builder or design professional.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Move TABLE second, unanimous. Remove from table, second, 11-0.  Second  Aye 0  Nay 11   NAR By request of proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 11 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
405.2.1
 3715 
Maintains more adequate insulation levels in ceilings.
Darrell Winters
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11   NAR    Not needed.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405.3
 3945 
This proposal adds clarity by repeating the most crucial element of the performance option – the 0.80 adjustment factor – in both Section 405 and Normative Appendix B.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Second   Move that is “less than or equal to 80 percent of the Standard Reference Design”  Move “without the Supplement effective October 31, 2007” second, unanimous. Move mod as amended Second.  Aye  11 Nay  0  AM    Move Normative B, Section B-1.1.1 consistent with 405.3. second, unanimous.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405.4.1
 4462 
This modification reinstates original IECC language.
Jack Glenn
4
Comment
Move to table  second  11-0 Remove from table, second unanimous. Second  Move add “and be” provided… before “provided to the…”    Aye   Nay  
Mod as amended Aye 9 Nay 1 1 abstention  AM  Modification provided clarification.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405.6
 4457 
This modification introduces the option for approved computing software energy compliance
Jack Glenn
4
Comment
Second    Move “Only compliance software compliance tools as approved …”  second 9 – 1 , 1 abstension  Move mod as amended   Aye 9  Nay1 1 abstention AM  Clarify

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations
1

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 12 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
405.6 (Appendix B)
 4461 
This modification introduces the option for approved computing software energy compliance
Jack Glenn
4
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405.6, Table B‑1.1.2(1)
 3947 
This proposal removes trade‑offs that are not allowed under the 2009 IECC performance path, including the programmable thermostat credit, the cross‑ventilation and whole house fan options, and an oversimplified credit for thermal storage mass.
Eric Lacey
4
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  No point in eliminating viable energy saving options from the performance path. 

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
405.6.6
 4378 
Replace Florida standard FL1 with AHRI Standard 470; and return the net useful heat exchange effect to the 2004 Code level 0f 50%.
John Borzoni
4
Comment
Second      Aye 10  Nay  1AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502
 4059 
Modify shell building efficiency requirements in view of return on investment
Mangesh Basarkar
5
Comment
Second      Aye 10  Nay  1  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 13 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
502
 4060 
Propose new envelope prescriptive requirements for alterations and renovations
Mangesh Basarkar
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.1.1
 4286 
Adding perscriptive insulation and fenestration requirements for New Construction.
Amy Schmidt
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Would weaken the code.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.1.1.1
 3573 
Reinstate the IECC 2009 Table 502.3 with an overall 20% reduction in heat transfer in lieu of fenestration values contained in 502.1.1.1 (1) &amp;(2).
Michael Nau
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Table is extraneous.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.1.1.1
 4240 
PROPOSED CHANGE IN THERMAL ENVELOPE REQUIREMENTS FOR SPECIAL USE STRUCTURES
WILLIAM KALKER
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11   NAR   Consistent with previous action.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 14 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
502.1.1.1 (1)
 4324 
Changes to SHGC and U‑factor in TABLE 502.1.1.1 (1)
Amanda Hickman
5
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.1.1.1 (2)
 4325 
Revision to SHGC and U‑factor values in TABLE 502.1.1.1 (2)
Amanda Hickman
5
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.1.1.1(1)&amp;(2)
 3919 
Coordinate Skylight U‑Factor and SHGC requirements with ASHRAE 90.1‑2007, in general.
Roger LeBrun
5
Comment
Second      Aye 1  Nay  10  NAR  No FL specific need.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.2.1.1
 4267 
Modifiying requirements to coincide with new tables.
Amy Schmidt
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 15 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
502.2.5
 4329 
502.2.5.1 Shell buildings, renovations and alterations can comply with related modifcation new section 502.2.5.1.3.
Amanda Hickman
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR   Consistent with previous action.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.2.5.1.1
 3926 
Allow for higher percentage of skylight area when automatic multi‑level lighting controls are utilized.
Roger LeBrun
5
Comment
Second      Aye  0 Nay  11  NAR  Weakens the code, not FL specific.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
502.2.5.1.3 (New)
 4327 
Adds a new section: 502.2.5.1.3 on Permanent Shading through different compliance paths on how to meet the requirements of Table 502.1.1.1.
Amanda Hickman
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0   Nay  11  NAR  Consistent with previous action.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503
 4061 
Modification to reference (baseline) building HVAC equipment suppy and return fan power calculation
Mangesh Basarkar
5
Comment
Second Move that A1 modify original proposal, second, unanimous. Move mod as amended.second     Aye 11  Nay  0  AM  Correlate to IECC terminology.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 16 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
503.2.1
 4056 
Oversight, Reference to ACCA Manual N was left out
Robert Volin
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.3
 3673 
Add room air conditioners and room air conditioner heat pump requirements to Table 503.2.3(3).
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.3
 4084 
Corrects treatment of &quot;small duct high velocity&quot; and Space constrained products and corrects the title of Table 503.2.3(2).
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.3
 4115 
The DOE is expanding it's  verification of efficiency ratings and increasing it's enforcement in this area.  Meeting their requirements, therefore, should be acceptable for the State of Florida.
roger cummins
5
Comment
Second      Aye 1  Nay   10  NAR   System performances are already covered by federal statute. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 17 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
503.2.3(10)
 3675 
Add performance requirements for heat rejection equipment back into the code that were not included in the IECC.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.3(3)
 3736 
Update minimum efficiencies for single packaged vertical air conditioners and heat pumps to the efficiencies required by Addendum b to ASHRAE 90.1‑2004.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.3(5)
 4057 
Update efficiency requirements for gas‑ and oil‑fired boilers to Addenda an to ASHRAE 90.1‑2004.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 10  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.6
 4042 
Change outside air supply from 70% to 30%
Amanda Hickman
5
Comment
Second      Aye  1  Nay 8  NAR   Not adequately justified.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 18 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
503.2.7.1.1
 3717 
Eliminates the reduced insulation levels being introduced into the code.
Darrell Winters
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay 11  NAR Weakens the code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.7.2
 3712 
Revise Table 503.2.7.2, Duct system construction and sealing, to include updates to the mechanical provisions of the Mechanical code and Residential code from the 2009 I‑codes. Resolve oversights of Florida‑specific reqts, formatting issues.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
503.2.8
 3720 
Eliminate proposed new Table 503.2.8 and use original Table 503.2.8 in IECC.
Darrell Winters
5
Comment
Second      Aye 3  Nay 8  NAR  Cost prohibitive.  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
504.7
 4415 
This proposal removes new s. 504.7.4 that would require energy efficiency pool pump and pump motor requirements for commercial pools.  The intent of the legislative directive was for these requirements to only apply for residential pools and spas.  They are not feasible in commercial applications.
Jennifer Hatfield
5
Comment
Second  Move alternate language provided at TAC meeting, second, unanimous.    Aye Move mod as amended, second Aye 11   Nay 0 AM  Consistent with previous action.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 19 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
504.7.3
 4410 
This proposal removes the cover requirements for pools &amp; spas and clarifies that the R‑12 insulation requirement for covers is only required for portable spas.  The current requirements pose serious safety hazards and may not be enforceable or realistic in certain commercial applications.
Jennifer Hatfield
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay 1   NAR Consistent with previous action. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
504.8
 3851 
Add Florida‑specific water flow control requirements from Florida code into IECC base.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
505.5
 4265 
Correct section formatting to clarify that the Total connected interior lighting power and Interior lighting Power are general criteria while sec. 505.5.1 applies to shell buildings, renovations and alterations.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
505.5.1.2.3
 3864 
Add Florida‑specific criteria for calculating luminaire wattage. Correct from Addenda i to ASHRAE 90.1‑04.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 20 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
505.5.3
 4426 
Add footnotes to Table 505.5.3 from Table 5.5.2 of the IECC.
Ann Stanton
5
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
505.6
 4467 
This modification introduces the option for approved computing software energy compliance
Jack Glenn
5
Comment
Move consistent with 4457 Second 10-0    Move mod as amended  Aye 10  Nay  0  AM   Consistent with 4457. 

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
506
 4300 
Reduce heating and cooling roof heat flux rates by 45% for vegetative roofs in commercial whole building performance code compliance calculations.
Jeff Sonne
5
Comment
Move consider A1 modification, second 11-0 Move mod as amended  second 11-0  AM  Implementing work groups recommendations.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
506.2
 3954 
This proposal removes an exception from the mandatory minimum R‑19 ceiling insulation requirement, ensuring a reasonable level of efficiency, regardless of the type of ceiling construction selected by the builder or design professional.
Eric Lacey
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Negative vote requested by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 21 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
506.2.1
 4299 
Deletes requirements in Section 506.2.1 that are to be covered by proposed section 502.1.1.2.
Amy Schmidt
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Negative vote requested by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
506.2.1
 4408 
Increase the mandatory roof R‑value under section 506.2.1 from R‑10 to R‑17.
Jeff Mang
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Negative vote requested by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
506.2.1
 4413 
Remove the “space permitting” exception to the mandatory roof R‑value for multiple‑family residential roofs under section 506.2.1.
Jeff Mang
5
Comment
Second      Aye 0  Nay  11  NAR  Negative vote requested by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
506.3
 4293 
Addition of credit for use of Energy Ventilation (ERV) Systems in performance method
Mangesh Basarkar
5
Comment
Second      Aye  0  Nay  11  NAR Unclear or insufficient information
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 22 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
AHAM
 3674 
Add standard for room air conditioners and room air conditioner heat pump requirements to Standards chapter.
Ann Stanton
6
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay 0   AS 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AHRI
 3865 
Update to AHRI 340/360‑2004.
Ann Stanton
6
Comment
Move A1 second 11-0 Move mod as amended, second 11-0 AM
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
ASHRAE
 3846 
Update to most recent standard.
Ann Stanton
6
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
ASTM
 4442 
Add standards into the code previously contained in the Florida energy code to reference insulation installation and thermal property testing standards.
Ann Stanton
6
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 23 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
CTI
 3676 
Add standard for heat rejection equipment back into the code that were not included in the IECC.
Ann Stanton
6
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
n/a
 3929 
1.  Update NFRC Standard referenced numbers.
2.  Correct WDMA address
Roger LeBrun
6
Comment
Second      Aye 11 Nay  0  AS   Standards are downloadable.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
Referenced Standards
 4062 
Referenced Manual in code
Robert Volin
6
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0   AS   Move reconsider second 11-0  Second  Move amend year to standard to 2004 second, unanimous. Move approve mod as amended, second 11-0 AM  Correct year. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
Appendix A
 3642 
Corrects jurisdiction names and college names in Florida Energy Conservation Code, Appendix A, Jurisdictional Data
Jon Hamrick
7
Comment
Move amend to change additional college names, second, unanimous.  Move mod with amendment  Second      Aye 11 Nay 0 AM  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 24 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
B‑1.1.2(1)
 3643 
Update internal gains equation for standard reference design home.
Jeff Sonne
8
Comment
Second      Aye  10  Nay  1  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
B‑1.1.2(1)
 3951 
This proposal removes the HVAC efficiency from the performance path calculation, consistent with the 2009 IECC.  It will save a significant amount of energy over the lifetime of the home.
Eric Lacey
8
Comment
Second      Aye 1   Nay  10  NAR  Confirm with federal law.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
B‑1.1.2(2)
 4181 
Include multiple space heating and cooling fuel types in section 405 simulated energy performance residential energy code compliance calculations.
Jeff Sonne
8
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay 0  AS 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
B‑2.6.1
 4429 
Add alternative to Table B‑2.6.1 regarding VAV with reheat to be consistent with Addenda am to ASHRAE 90.1‑04.
Ann Stanton
8
Comment
Second      Aye 11  Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 25 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Energy Conservation
FL Std 2
 4072 
Provides criteria on how to comply with section 403.9 of the FECC; parts of which are legislative directive.  This document is the APSP‑15 Draft Standard for Energy Efficiency for Residential Inground Swimming Pools &amp; Spas that the FBC Energy Workgroup recommended for adoption into the 2010 code
Jennifer Hatfield
10
Comment
Second      Aye 9  Nay  0 AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
FL Std 3
 4077 
Provides criteria on how to comply w/ s. 403.9.5 of the FECC; the mandatory requirement for portable spas, per legislative directive. This document is the APSP‑14 draft Standard for Portable Spa Energy Efficiency that provides the test protocol manufacturers must use when determining standby power.
Jennifer Hatfield
10
Comment
 Move A1 second 10-0  Move mod as amended second 10-0 AM  with A1.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Existing Building
311
 4025 
Change reference to new volume of the code.
Jack Glenn
3
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
612.1
 4026 
Editorial to correct a code reference.
Jack Glenn
6
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 26 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Existing Building
711.1
 4027 
Editorial to correct a code reference.
Jack Glenn
7
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
808.1
 4028 
Editorial to correct a code reference.
Jack Glenn
8
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
913
 4029 
Editorial to correct a code reference.
Jack Glenn
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1006.1
 4030 
Editorial to correct a code reference.
Jack Glenn
10
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Mechanical
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 27 of 28
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Energy
TAC:
 107 
SubCode:
Mechanical
202
 3749 
Revise Air Conditioning definition
J Glenn‑BASF
2
Comment
Second   Aye 10 Nay 0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
202
 3750 
Definition of Air Distribution system retain the based code (IMC) language
J Glenn‑BASF
2
Comment
Second   Aye 10 Nay 0  AS  

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
202
 3756 
Retain the based code (IMC) language
J Glenn‑BASF
2
Comment
Second   Aye 0 Nay 10  NAR  Def is insufficient

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Residential
806.4
 4051 
Retain base code (IRC) language.
J Glenn‑BASF
8
Comment
  Move delete #4 to remove not FL specific, second, 10-0  Move mod as amended, second 10-0  AM  Make Florida specific.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 28 of 28
6/25/2010
Modification #:
Code Change Cycle:
Chapter & Topic:
Date Submitted From:
TAC:
Proponent Last Name:
Affects HVHZ:
Sub Code:
Code Version:
Commission Action:
Text of Modification:
Section:
Related Modifications:
TAC Recommendation:
Date Submitted To:
Proponent First Name:
2010
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
Search Criteria
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations