Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 1 of 44
6/25/2010
Code Change Cycle:
2010 Triennial Original Modification 3/1/2010 ‑ 4/2/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
202
 3399 
Provide a definition of &quot;valley&quot;
William Dumbaugh
2
Comment
Second Boyer. Cone: Add to definition:  “…opposite to hip.” Amendment to Mod 3399: 4 Aye, 4 Opposed, Fails. Zehnal:  Propose new language (see Rev): Seconded Warseck, 6 Ave, 2 Opposed, Passes. Mod AM, 8 – 0 passes. Reason: Additional clarification.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1502.1
 3803 
Add definition for Roof System and clarify Roof Covering System.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Second Hamrick. Schulte: Amend to clarify “structural substrate”: No second. ModO 3803 4 Aye 4 No. Fails. NAR.  No Florida specific need.  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1502.1
 4162 
Adds a new definition to Chapter 1502.1 for photovoltaic modules/shingles.
Lorraine Ross
15
Comment
Boyer second. Ave 0 Opposed 7, 1 abstain. Fails. NAR. No Fl specific need.  Ross: Motion to reconsider. Second. Aye  7  Nay  1. New definition provided by Ross.  Aye 7   Nay     . 1 AM   Broadens definition to address previous concerns.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1502.1 Definitions
 3683 
Add the requirement that exterior mounted cooling towers, fluid coolers, and evaporative condensers, which are subjected to wind forces be designed as a structure, to the FBC Building Code, volume.
Mark Speckin
15
Comment
Boyer second. 2 Aye, 6 No. NAR Reason: Already covered in the Mechanical code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 2 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1503.4.2.1
 3623 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Zehnal Second. 5 Aye, 3 No. NAR.  Not FL specific. There are life safety issues.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1503.5
 3984 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it provides the same direction and result.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer Second.  Schulte: Proposed mod to add Approved. No second. 5 Aye, 3 No. NAR. FRSA position that there is a FL specific need.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1503.6
 3983 
Retain base code (IBC) language as the FBC exception does not provide specific direction.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer Second. 6 Aye, 2Nay. AS. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1503.6
 4334 
Clarifies that skylights are to be installed and flashed in accordance with manufacturers instructions; provides an exception to requirement for crickets
Chuck Anderson
15
Comment
 Boyer Second. Aye 0 Nay 8, NAR. Proposed mod would diminish the code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 3 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1504, 1507
 4217 
This modification is a correlation to the modification that updates ASCE 7 to the 2010 Edition and introduces new ultimate design wind speed maps in the code.
T Stafford
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Aye 0 Nay 8. NAR. Not  in IBC base code  yet.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1504.7
 3982 
Remove the listed exemptions.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Zehnal Second. Aye 4 Nay 4. NAR. There is a FL specific need for the exemption. The proposal would weaken the code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1504.8
 3981 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it provides for better protection.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Cone Second. Aye 1 Nay 7 NAR. There is a FL specific need. There is a fiscal impact.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1505.7
 3980 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it provides increased protection.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Cone Second. Aye 0 Nay 8 NAR. No Florida specific. There is no definition for special purpose roof, not FL specific.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 4 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1506.1
 3622 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Aye 1  Nay  7 NAR, Redundant because of other FL statute, e.g. Product Approval.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507,
 4201 
This proposal specifies methods for a secondary water barrier under roof coverings for new construction.
T Stafford
15
Comment
Cone Second. Aye 0  Nay 8 Aye   NAR  . There is a cost impact.   
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.15
 3814 
Liquid‑applied roof coatings.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Zehnal move Table. Aye  8 Nay  0  Ross remove from table. Second. Warseck move (new) amended language. Second. Aye  8 Nay  0 . 
Original mod Aye  7 Nay  1. AM  Clarify issue. Reopen Ross. Second, Unanimous. Amend to same language language as 3799. Aye 8   Nay    0 . Mod as amended Aye  8  Nay 0  AM Provides consistency with HVHZ, clarifies code.      
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.15
 4360 
Create new section to 1507.15
chris schulte
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 1  Nay  7 NAR. Not Florida specific.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 5 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1507.2.7
 3979 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it provides similar results.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Aye 5  Nay  3 NAR Feel FL specific need for existing language
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.2.9.1
 3625 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Zehnal Second. Schulte amend mod to 4x4. Aye  6 Nay 2. Amendment passes. AM Aye  7 Nay  1. Consistent with other sections of the code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.2.9.1
 3738 
Base and counter flashing.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.2.9.1
 3806 
Base and counter flashing; to make code consistent.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 6 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1507.2.9.1
 3807 
Base and counter flashing clarification.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
   Second.   Zehnal, remove “either”. Approved unanimously. Aye 5  Nay  3 NAR. Discriminates against product; code is a minimum Not FL specific.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.2.9.2
 3809 
Make valley's consistent.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Change mm to 16” equivalent. AM Aye  8 Nay  0.  Need to fix metric conversion.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.2.9.3
 3810 
Make drip edge consistent with FBC Residential code.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
AM Aye  8 Nay  0.  Need to fix metric conversion
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.1
 3977 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it produces similar results
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Aye  1 Nay  7.  NAR Proposal weakens the code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations
Comment

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 7 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1507.3.2
 4183 
Adds additonal options for concrete and clay roof tile installations.
Pate Lisa
15
Cone second. Aye 6  Nay  2  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.3
 3824 
Allows for additional installation options of concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Zehnal Second. Aye  6 Nay  2  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.3, 1507.3.8, 1507.3.9, 1507.4.5
 3645 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Withdrawn by
Proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.3.1
 3825 
Allows additional options for installation of concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Zehnal Second. Schulte, move amend to add TRI 07320. Cone amend, Warseck Second. Aye 6  Nay  2 AM. Need to include manual number.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 8 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1507.3.6
 3826 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Warseck second. Aye 6  Nay  2 AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.7
 3827 
Allow for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Zehnal Second. Schulte amend to add “or the manufacturers product approval”. Second. Take RAS 118, 119, 120 out. Aye  0 Nay  8.  Original mod Aye 0   Nay  8. NAR Reference given is incomplete.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.8
 3828 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Zehnal Second. Aye 6  Nay  2 AS.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.3.9
 3829 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Warseck Second. Aye 6  Nay  2 AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 9 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1507.4.3(1)
 3816 
Metal Roof Covering tables consistent.
Pate Lisa
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Aye 2  Nay  6. NAR. No FL specific need.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.7
 3976 
Retain the base code (IBC) language as it provides better direction, more options 
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer second. Fix mm conversion. Aye 2  Nay  6. NAR  Dimensions are not consistent internally. Goes against prior decisions that were FL specific. Requirement addresses a northern snow need.  It would degrade the code. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.8.8
 3974 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it provides better direction and more options.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer second. Aye 0 Nay 8  NAR There is a demonstrated FL specific need to retain this provision.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1507.9.9
 3975 
Retain base code (IBC) language as it provides better direction and more options.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Seconded Aye 0  Nay 8  NAR There is a demonstrated FL specific need to retain this provision.
.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 10 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1508.2
 3614 
Request modification of the table of insulations 1508.2  This modification reflects the clarification of types of approved expanded polystyrene insulations as shown in TAS 110.
THOMAS SAVOY
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Ross move remove date reference. Goldsmith second: Aye 8 Nay 0. Mod Aye 0  Nay 8. NAR Code adequately addresses the issue. 

Procponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1509 Rooftop Structure
 3684 
Add the requirement that exterior mounted cooling towers which are subjected to wind forces, be designed as a structure, to the FBC Building Code, volume.
Mark Speckin
15
Comment
Boyer Second. Aye 1  Nay 7 NAR  Already covered in Mechanical code.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1510.1, 1515.2.2.1, 1524.1.5
 4369 
Clarification
Scott Thompson
15
Comment
Ross second. Aye 1 Nay 7  NAR. Unnecessary cost burden. Weakens the code. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1510.3
 3428 
When recovering a roof, Code requires removal of existing two coverings.
two coverings. This Mod would allow a third covering of  for single plyply Thermoplastic (TPO), as it is lightweight and little resistance to 
refastening, and is energy efficient..
Willaim McConaghey
15
Comment
Cone second. Aye 0  Nay 8 NAR  Limits material that can be used.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 11 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1510.3
 4270 
Add a 3rd exception to allow for the installation of a single ply roof over two layers of exisitng roof.
Mike Ennis
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 1 Nay 7   NAR  Not FL specific. Discriminates against other
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1510.3
 4361 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Withdrawn.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1511
 4308 
This modification will provide a uniform roofing application throughout the state.
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 1  Nay 7 NAR. No FL specific need, local issue.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1511.1
 4326 
This modification will create a form to be used by the roofing contractor to discuss with the building owner common issues associated with reroofing and or waterproofing projects.
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 0 Nay 8.  NAR. Not appropriate for the code.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 12 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1512.1
 3795 
This modification recognizes the use of waterproofing in the roofing chapter
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Cone second. Aye 2 Nay 6 NAR. No FL specific needs.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1513
 3722 
adding a needed definition to the roofing chapter.
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 1 Nay 7 NAR. Doesn’t belong in Ch 15.  No technical basis.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1513
 3724 
Adding a needed definition to the roofing chapter.
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 1 Nay 7 NAR. Doesn’t belong in Ch 15.  No technical basis.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1513
 4455 
Adds a new definition to Section 1513 for photovoltaic modules/shingles.
Lorraine Ross
15
Comment
Boyer second. Aye 3 Nay 5  NAR   Product specific, needs to be broadened.  Ross move to reconsider. Second. Amend as per 4148. Aye  7  Nay1.  AM  Strengthens code .
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 13 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1515.2
 3702 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Boyer second . Zehnal propose amend original table to clarify,,,  Propose TABLE Aye 8 Nay 2. Cone move remove from table. Second. Boyer move use new amendment. Aye  8 Nay  0 . Mod with amendment Aye  8 Nay  0  AM    Clarification of code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1517.5.2, 1519.5.1.1
 3699 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Second. Warseck: amend to reference back to section 1517.5.2. second. Aye 8 Nay 0. Original mod Aye 7 Nay 1 AM Clarify provisions.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1517.6.2.3
 3705 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Second. Aye  8 Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1518.2.3
 3703 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Warseck second. Aye  8 Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 14 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1521.17.1
 3799 
This modification adds a specific code reference relevant to the asphalt shingle section.
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Second. Wordsmithed. Motion to TABLE. Aye unanimous.  Warseck move remove from TABLE. Second. Aye.  Boyer move. Second. Aye  8  Nay   0. As modified. Aye 8    Nay  0 AM. Clarifies mod.     
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1521.8
 3707 
Clarification
chris schulte
15
Comment
Zehnal second. Aye  7 Nay  1  AS  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1523.6.5.2.9
 3798 
This modification corrects a typo
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Second… Amend to remove RAS 117. Second. Aye  8 Nay  0  AM Clarify code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1524
 3716 
adding water proofing to the 1524 owners notification form
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Warseck second. Aye  1 Nay  7 NAR Not properly placed in the roofing chapter.  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 15 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1525
 3753 
Update High‑Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Form
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Ross second. Aye  8 Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1525
 3762 
Update High‑Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Form with additional category
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Warseck second. Aye  1 Nay  7  NAR  Not appropriate for the roofing chapter.  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1525
 3781 
This modification corrects a typo in the High Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Section C
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Cone second. Aye  8 Nay  0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1525
 3789 
Adds missing language in Section C of the High‑Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Form
Mark Zehnal
15
Comment
Ross second. Aye  7 Nay  1  AS  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 16 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
1525 Section E ‑ Method 3
 3534 
This modification corrects a typo in the High Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Section E ‑ Method 3(Tile Calculations).
Jaime Gascon
15
Comment
Warseck second.  Aye  8 Nay  0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
New 1505.8
 4272 
Add a new section to the code (1505.8) to define the method designing a vegatative (Garden) roof for fire resistance as required by the code.
Mike Ennis
15
Comment
Ross second. Aye  1 Nay  7  NAR  No FL specific need, not in the base document. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
New Section 1505.8
 4170 
Adds fire classification requirement for photovoltaic modules/shingles roofing products.
Lorraine Ross
15
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  8 Nay  0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
New section 1507.17
 4163 
Adds new sections regarding use of photovoltaic modules/shingles as roof coverings.
Lorraine Ross
15
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  4 Nay  4  NAR  No FL specific need, not in base code.  Motion to reconsider, second. Aye  7  Nay   1. Add “building integrated PV roofing” to conform to rest of amendments, second. Aye  7  Nay   1.  Ross move to approve mod as amended, second. Aye  7  Nay   1.   AM   Broaden scope 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Aye    Nay     Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 17 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
New section 1518.11
 4456 
Adds new sections regarding use of photovoltaic modules/shingles as roof coverings.
Lorraine Ross
15
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  3  Nay  5  NAR   No real need for this, just adding a component.  Move to reconsider, second. Aye  7  Nay   1.  Take out installation instructions same as 4454. Move to amend, second. Aye  7  Nay   1.  Move mod as amended, second, Aye  7  Nay   1.   AM    Broaden scope.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
Section 1504.9
 4180 
Clarifies wind testing requirements for Photovoltaic modules/shingles
Lorraine Ross
15
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  4  Nay     4  NAR. No FL specific need. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
Table 1507.8
 3963 
Retain base code (IBC) Table as it provides the same level of protection as the Florida Code Table.
J Glenn‑BASF
15
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 0    Nay    8 NAR Proposal not clear. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1617.3
 4235 
Contents of this section are given in Plumbing code, This modification is to remove duplication.
Mohammed Shaikh
16
Comment
Warseck second. Aye 0   Nay 8  NAR Current code has more clarity.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations
0

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 18 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
NA
 4257 
Insert correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
35
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
NA
 4259 
Insert correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
35
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
NA
 4261 
Inserting correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
35
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
NA
 4262 
Inserting correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
35
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 19 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Building
New standard
 4152 
Adds a new standard to Chapter 35 for photovoltaic modules/shingles. UL 1703 is attached as a separate file.
Lorraine Ross
35
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  7  Nay 1 AS     
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
New appendix
 4391 
Add a new Appendix “XX” (Designation to be assigned)
Doug Harvey
2711
Comment
Ross second. Aye1   Nay  7 NAR  Document is not yet a reference standard.   
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Existing Building
501.1
 3801 
This modification adds an exception for missing roof repair language specific to the HVHZ.
Mark Zehnal
5
Comment
Zehnal second. Aye 2   Nay    6  NAR    Undue burden on repair cost.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
611.2‑611.6
 3820 
Altering roof covering on existing buildings.
Pate Lisa
6
Comment
Second.  Aye 3   Nay  5  NAR May conflict with Statuatory requirements.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 20 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Existing Building
611.3
 3822 
Recovering versus replacement of roof coverings.
Pate Lisa
6
Comment
Cone second. Zehnal propose take the exception for HVHZ in original language and add it below, renumber. Aye 8  Nay  0.  Mod as amended. Aye 8   Nay  0. AM  Make code consistent while including HVHZ.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
611.3
 4171 
The modification prohibits the installation of new asphalt shingles over existing asphalt shingles in a reroofing application.
T Stafford
6
Comment
Second. Aye 0   Nay 8  NAR  Would weaken code.  Cost impact.    
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
611.7‑611.8.1.7
 3821 
Move Roof Covering on Florida Building Code, Existing Building to FBC Residential code for clarity.
Pate Lisa
6
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
611.8.1.7
 3849 
Staff proposes change to reflect the findings of the Florida Building Commission in Declaratory Statement DCA09‑DEC‑045 which clarifies the scope of work requirements mandated under the 15 % of cost to re‑roof.
Jon Caudill
6
Comment
Boyer second. Editorial  change to “portion”. Aye 8   Nay  0.  AM 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Residential
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 21 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
New definition
 4148 
Adds a definition for photovoltaic modules/shingles.
Lorraine Ross
2
Comment
Boyer second. Ross propose amendment to language. Second. Aye  8  Nay  0.  Mod as amended. Aye 7   Nay  1. AM Strengthens the code by providing a broader definition..   
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
902.1
 4052 
Retain base code (IRC) language.
J Glenn‑BASF
9
Comment
Zehnal second. Zehnal amend to strike #2. Second  Aye 1   Nay 7  Original mod  Aye 0   Nay  8.  NAR.  Would weaken the code.       
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
903.2.2
 4053 
Retain base code (IRC) language.
J Glenn‑BASF
9
Comment
Zehnal second. Aye  3  Nay     5  NAR   Current FL language is sufficient, more clear.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
903.2.2
 4335 
Clarifies that skylights are to be installed and flashed in accordance with manufacturers instructions; provides an exception to requirement for crickets
Chuck Anderson
9
Comment
Warseck:  Aye   0 Nay   8.  NAR   Use rationale for commercial rebuff . Not yet in base code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 22 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
903.4.1
 4054 
Retain base code (IRC) language
J Glenn‑BASF
9
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 4   Nay  4  NAR  Weakens the code by removing overflow drains. Takes sizing away from the plumbing code.  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
905.10.3(1)
 4365 
Replacing Metal Roof Covering table in Florida Building Code, Residential and using Metal Roof Covering table in Florida Building Code, Building.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Boyer second. Cone move amend to return to original gauge metal. Second. Unanimious. AM  Aye 8   Nay  0.  Need to add roof coverings not on table, retain original metal gauge.    
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
905.4.3
 4055 
Retain base code (IRC) language
J Glenn‑BASF
9
Comment
Boyer second. Aye 3   Nay   5 NAR.     Weakens the code because it wouldn’t meet FL reqts.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
905.4.4
 4363 
Replacing Metal Roof Covering table in Florida Building Code, Residential and using Metal Roof Covering table in Florida Building Code, Building.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Boyer second. Boyer amend to remove new gauges. Aye  8  Nay  0    AM. Brought chart back to original gauge.   Staff should check to propose corrections for any correlation issue.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 23 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
New section ‑R905.16
 4144 
Adds new sections regarding use of photovoltaic modules/shingles as roof covering materials.
Lorraine Ross
9
Comment
Ross move Table. Second. Unanimious  Boyer move remove from table, second. Aye  8  Nay   0.  Boyer move to amend, second. Aye  7 Nay   1. Goldsmith move mod as amended, second.. Aye  7 Nay   1. Amend to conform to new definition.   AM
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R903.4.1
 3624 
Clarification
chris schulte
9
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  2  Nay   5 NAR.  Changes the meaning of code language. Not a FL specific reqt.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R904.1
 3621 
Clarification
chris schulte
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R904.4.3, R905.2.3, R905.5.3, R905.5.4
 3627 
Consistency of language
chris schulte
9
Comment

Zehnal second. Aye  2  Nay     6 NAR.  No FL specific need.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 24 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R905
 4202 
This proposal specifies methods for a secondary water barrier under roof coverings for new construction.
T Stafford
9
Comment
Boyer second. Aye  0  Nay   8.NAR.  There is a FL specific need for what is currently in the code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905
 4228 
This modification is a correlation to the modification that updates ASCE 7 to the 2010 Edition.
T Stafford
9
Comment
Boyer second. Aye   0 Nay    8 NAR.  Unclear. ASCE 7-10 is not an adopted standard. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.2.2
 3804 
To make slope consistent with Florida Building Codes, Building sections 1507.2.2 and 1507.2.8.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Cone second.   Aye 4   Nay  4  NAR,   No FL specific need for the change.                       
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.2.8.1
 3626 
Clarification
chris schulte
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 25 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R905.2.8.1
 3808 
Clarify base and counter flashing.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3
 3830 
Allows for additonal installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Zehnal second. Aye  6  Nay    2.  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.2     38313831
  33831383138313831ye    Nay     3831 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Warseck seconded. Aye  6  Nay  2 AS                     3831   
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.2
 4184 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent  .
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 26 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R905.3.3
 3832 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Second.  Aye 6   Nay    2  AS 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.3.1
 3833 
Allows for additional installation option for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Cone second. Aye 6   Nay   2  AS  
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.6
 3834 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Warseck second. Aye  5  Nay     3  NAR.  Mixes two code sections. Ross move to reconsider. Second. Unanimous. Aye  6  Nay  2  AS   
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.6
 4164 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 27 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R905.3.7
 3835 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Cone second. Cone amend remove ref to RAS from attachment section. No second.  Original mod Aye 2   Nay  6  NAR     RASes do not specify uplift or attachment values.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.7.1
 3836 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Cone second. Aye  2  Nay  6 NAR   Weakens the code.   
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.8
 3837 
Allows for additional installation options for concrete and clay roof tile.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 6    Nay 2		AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.4.4
 3815 
Strengthening the Metal Roof Coverings table.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 28 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R905.4.4
 3817 
Material standards for Metal Roof Coverings.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R908
 4283 
Move Roof Covering on Florida Building Code, Existing Building to FBC Residential code for clarity.
Pate Lisa
9
Comment
Cone second.  Fix ? to “.  Aye  0   Nay 8  NAR   Per FL approach to existing buildings, don’t need this.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R908
 4323 
This modification by removing the (High Velocity Hurricane Zone) language will provide a uniform roofing application throughout the state.
Mark Zehnal
9
Comment
Withdrawn.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R908.1
 4330 
This modification will create a form to be used by the roofing contractor to discuss with the building owner common issues associated with reroofing and or waterproofing projects.
Mark Zehnal
9
Comment
Withdrawn.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 29 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
New standard
 4151 
Adds a new standard  ‑ UL 1703 ‑to Chapter 43 for photovoltaic modules/shingles. UL 1703 is attached for review.
Lorraine Ross
43
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye  7   Nay 1  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
New standard
 4269 
Adds a new standard  ‑ UL 1741 ‑to Chapter 43 for electrical aspects of photovoltaic modules/shingles installation. UL 1741 is attached for review.
Lorraine Ross
43
Comment
Ross motion to Table. Second. Unanimous.   Relevant to E4268. Move to remove from table, second. Aye  8  Nay   0.  Ross second mod. Aye  7  Nay   1    AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3
 4250 
Inserting correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
43
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R905.3.3
 4252 
Inserting correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
43
Comment
Withdrawn.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 30 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R905.3.7.1
 4253 
Inserting correct edition of standard reference document.
Pate Lisa
43
Comment
Withdrawn.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
4402.13
 3719 
adding waterproofing to the 4402.13 owners notification form
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye  1   Nay 7  NAR   Not roofing issue.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
4402.2
 3726 
Adding a needed definition to the roofing chapter.
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Second. Aye 1    Nay 7  NAR   Doesn’t belong in the roofing section.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
4402.2
 3727 
Adding a needed definition to the roofing chapter.
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Boyer second. Aye 1   Nay  7   NAR              Not a scientific definition
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 31 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
New section ‑R4402.7.11
 4454 
Adds new sections regarding use of photovoltaic modules/shingles as roof covering materials.
Lorraine Ross
44
Comment
Warseck motion to Table, second. Unanimous.  Move to remove from Table, second, 8 0. Move to amend per alternate language, second. Aye  7  Nay   1. . Amend to say “shall be attached to manufacturer’s product approval.  Aye  7  Nay 1         Move to approve as amended, second Aye  7  Nay   1. AM Broaden language as requested by TAC.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.1.1
 3796 
This modification recognizes the use of waterproofing in throughout the roofing chapter
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Goldsmith second. Aye  1   Nay 7   NAR   Doesn’t belong in the roofing section.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.10.17.1
 3800 
This modification adds a specific code reference relevant to the asphalt shingle section.
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
  Cone second.  Amend per Mod 3814.  Goldsmith move amendment, second. Aye  7   Nay 0.   Mod as amended Aye 7    Nay 0   AM   Make consistent with 3814.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.10.8
 3708 
Clarification
chris schulte
44
Comment
Boyer second. Aye 8    Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 32 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R4402.12.6.5.2.9
 3797 
This modification corrects a typo
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Second. Aye  8   Nay 0  AM Delete RAS editorial
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.14
 3757 
Update High‑Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Form
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Second    Aye 8    Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.14
 3777 
Update High‑Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Form with additional category
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment6
Second.  Aye  1   Nay 6   NAR   Doesn’t belong in the roofing section.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.14
 3784 
This modification corrects a typo in the High Velocity Hurricane Zone Uniform Permit Application Section C
Mark Zehnal
44
Comment
Second.  Aye 8    Nay0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 33 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R4402.2
 4451 
Adds a definition for photovoltaic modules/shingles.
Lorraine Ross
44
Comment
Ross move to table, second, unanimous. Move to remove from Table, second, Aye  8  Nay   0.  Amend to use new language., second Aye  7  Nay   1. Move to approve as amended, second. Aye  7  Nay   1.   AM    Broaden scope of action.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.6.5.2, R4402.8.5.1.1
 3700 
Clarification
chris schulte
44
Comment
  Second..  Boyer amend to reference sec. 4402.6.5.2, second Aye 8    Nay0.  Mod with amendment Aye  8   Nay 0   AM  Remove duplicative language.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.6.6.2.3
 3706 
Clarification
chris schulte
44
Comment
Second.  Aye  8   Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
R4402.7.2.3
 3704 
Clarification
chris schulte
44
Comment
Zehnal second.   Aye 7    Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 34 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Residential
R4403.6.3
 4242 
Contents of this section are in Chapter 11 of the Plumbing Code. This section is proposed to be revised to avoid duplicity
Mohammed Shaikh
44
Comment
Zehnal second.  Aye  0   Nay 8  NAR   Wrong code.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
SubCode:
Test Protocols
5.4, 7.3, 10.2, 11.2
 4362 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Boyer second.  Aye 7    Nay 0  AM  Fix typos.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.01 A
 3531 
This modification provides additional clarification on tile installation procedures for adhered systems.
Jaime Gascon
1
Comment
Buckner second.   Aye  1   Nay 6   NAR   Language not clear enough.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.3, 8.4, 11.1.2
 3537 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Second. Schulte moved to amend the mod by 1) adding “registered design professional per F.S. 471 or 481”  to 1.3, 8.4 and 11.1.2 and 2) take RRC out of 1.3. Second.  
Aye 6    Nay 2   Move mod as amended. Aye 6    Nay 2   AM Consistent with State Statutes. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 35 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
1.4, 4.4.2, 7.8, 11.1.3
 3538 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Goldsmith seconds. Goldsmith: amend to return to “chief code compliance officer”. Expand to include Registered Design Professional per F.S., Section 471 or 481.Second Warseck. Aye  7   Nay 1 Move mod as amended Aye  8   Nay 0  AM  Makes consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
10.4
 4343 
Change the test application so TAS 101 can be used to determine the uplift resistance for adhesive set tile systems when an adhesive pad provides resistance for two or more roof tiles.
Richard Olson
1
Comment
Second.  Aye  8  Nay 0 AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
7.2.1, 7.6.4, 7.2.2, 10.3.3
 3539 
Corrections and additions
chris schulte
1
Comment
Warseck seconds. Aye  8   Nay 0 AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.4, 4.4.2, 7.2.1, 7.8, 10.1.3
 3540 
Clarifications
chris schulte
1
Comment
    Second.  Amend to put Chief Code Compliance Officer back in, use registered Design Professional per Section 471 or 481: Aye 7  Nay 1.  Motion to approve mod as amended, second. Aye   7  Nay 1 AM Be consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 36 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
1.4, 4.4.2, 7.2.1, 7.8, 10.1.4
 3541 
Clarifications
chris schulte
1
Comment
Goldsmith second. Move to approve amendment Aye  7   Nay 1 Move to approve mod as amended. Second. Aye    7 Nay 1 AM  Make consistent with FL Statute.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
22
 3628 
This modification is meant to clarify that the Granule Adhesion test is required for mineral surfaced underlayments that will be used for both mortar and adhesive set tile systems.
Jaime Gascon
1
Comment
Warseck second. Aye 8    Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
18
 3630 
This modification is meant to clarify that the granule adhesion test is required for mineral surfaced underlayments that will be used for both mortar and adhesive set tile systems.
Jaime Gascon
1
Comment
Warseck second.  Aye   8  Nay 0  AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
4.1, 10.1.2
 3543 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Warseck second. Amend to fix scribner’s errors:  attached and gripping. In 10.1.2 and add Registered Design Professional instead of PE, leave RCC. Second. Aye  6  Nay  1   Warseck: Move mod with amendment Aye  5   Nay 2  NAR  Weakens the code by providing an exception.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 37 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
4.1.2
 3527 
Typo ‑ 'arc' needs to be corrected to 'are'.
Jaime Gascon
1
Comment
Ross second. Aye  8   Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
11.1
 3544 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
4.1, 7.2.1, 7.11, 11.1.2
 3545 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Zehler seconds. Warseck move to amend to be consistent with previous mods. Aye 8    Nay 0, Warseck move as amended, second. Aye  8   Nay 0. AM Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
2.2
 3546 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Warseck second. Aye 8    Nay 0   AS
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 38 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
8. Roofing Insulation
 3474 
In the table of physical properties of Expanded Polystyrene, include density types I, VIII and II per ASTM C578. Currently on Type IX is included in TAS 110. Types I, VIII, II and IX are used commonly in approved roof assemblies. Additional Modifications to Chapter 15,section 1508.2(table)
THOMAS SAVOY
1
Comment
Cone second. Goldsmith: Modify to remove date of standard. (Revising Table 2.2). Aye 8    Nay 0  Move the mod with amendment. Second Aye 4    Nay 4  NAR Reduction in code stringency.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.3
 3547 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
            Second.  Move to amend to replace RCC with Registered Design Professional .  Aye 7  Nay 1   Mod as amended, second. Aye  7   Nay 1   AM  Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.3
 3548 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Second. Move to amend to remove RCC, add Registered Design Professional, second. Aye   6  Nay 1 Warseck Move mod as amended, second. Aye 7    Nay 1 AM  Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.3, 2.4
 3549 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
 Second. Goldsmith: Move to amend to signed by a Registered Design Professional per FS Sec. 471 or 481. Second. Aye 8    Nay 0  Ross: Move to fix ANSI/SPRI ES-1, second Aye 8     Nay 0 Move mod as amended, second. Aye  8  Nay 0   AM    Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 39 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
11.1, 3.4 (Appendix A)
 3550 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Warseck second. Warseck move to use Chief Code Compliance Officer, add signed by a Registered Design Professional per FS 471 or 481 instead of RCC, second Aye   8  Nay 0. Goldsmith move mod with amendment. Aye 8    Nay  8  AM  Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
4.4.1, 7.3.2, 8.1.1, 8.2.3, 8.3.2.1, 9.2.1.3
 3551 
Clarifications
chris schulte
1
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
Appendix D Section 5.5
 3532 
This modification adds clarification as to the number of test specimens required for this test standard.
Jaime Gascon
1
Comment
Warseck second.  Aye  5   Nay   5  NAR     Proposal is incomplete. 
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.4, 4.2, 4.3, 12.1.2
 3553 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
 Second. Warseck: Amend to reinstate Chief Code Compliance Official, Add Registered Design Professional, delete RCC except Sec. 11.? . Aye 8    Nay 0 Warseck: Move mod as amended, second, Aye  8 Nay 0  AM  Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 40 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
1.3
 3554 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
  Goldsmith second. Warseck:  Amend to Add Registered Design Professional…, Second, Aye  8   Nay 0 Warseck Move mod with amendment Aye  8   Nay 0
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.4
 3555 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
  Goldsmith second. Warseck:  Amend to Add Registered Design Professional…, Second, Aye  8   Nay 0 Warseck Move mod with amendment Aye  8   Nay 0  AM   Make consistent 

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.4
 3556 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
  Goldsmith second. Warseck:  Amend to Add Registered Design Professional…, Second, Aye  8   Nay 0 Warseck Move mod with amendment Aye  8   Nay 0   AM Make consistent  with FL Statute. 

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
8.2
 3558 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 41 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
10.1, 10.2
 3559 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.6
 3560 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
 Boyer second.   Schulte:  Amend to Add Registered Design Professional…^ put back CCCO, Second, Aye  8  Nay 0 Warseck: Move mod with amendment Aye  7   Nay 1   
AM   Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
1.3
 3561 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Goldsmith second.  Warseck: Amend to add Registered Design Professional, delete RRC, second.  Aye 7   Nay 1. Goldsmith move mod as amended, second. Aye 7   Nay 1   AM    Make consistent with FL Statutes.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
3.2.1
 4437 
Core Cut into lightweight Cocrecte and lightweight insulating concrete should have a acceptable moisture by weight content.
High moisture in LWC can have a long term affect on deck.
Katherine Cleary
1
Comment
Ross second. Amended per A6    Aye 6   Nay 2  AM   Rationale provided in amendment.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 42 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
11.2, 14.1
 3562 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
10.1, 10.2
 3563 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment
Withdrawn by proponent.
Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
11.1, 11.2
 3565 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment

Withdrawn by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
9.1, 9.2
 3566 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment

Withdrawn by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 43 of 44
6/25/2010
Total Mods for this TAC:
Roofing
TAC:
 172 
SubCode:
Test Protocols
8.1, 8.2
 3567 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment

Withdrawn by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
10.1, 10.2
 3568 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment

Withdrawn by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
9.1, 9.2
 3569 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment

Withdrawn by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
9.1, 9.2
 3570 
Clarification
chris schulte
1
Comment

Withdrawn by proponent.

Proponent
Summary
Mod #
Section
Chapter
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations

Florida Department of Community Affairs
Building Codes and Standards
TAC & Commission Tracking Chart
Page 44 of 44
6/25/2010
Modification #:
Code Change Cycle:
Chapter & Topic:
Date Submitted From:
TAC:
Proponent Last Name:
Affects HVHZ:
Sub Code:
Code Version:
Commission Action:
Text of Modification:
Section:
Related Modifications:
TAC Recommendation:
Date Submitted To:
Proponent First Name:
2010
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
ALL
Search Criteria
AS = Approved as Submitted
AM = Approved as Modified
NAR = No Affirmative Recommendation
W = Withdrawn
I = Insufficient (incomplete or does not meet criteria)
TAC Recommendations